Drawing with Charcoal: How to Choose the Right One to Draw With

Drawing with charcoal is a timeless art technique favoured for its rich, dark tones and versatile texture. Choosing the right charcoal can greatly impact your artwork, regardless of your experience level. Let’s delve into selecting the perfect charcoal for your drawing requirements.

1. Understanding Different Types of Charcoal

Before choosing the right charcoal, it’s essential to understand the different types available. There are mainly three types of charcoal used in drawing:

1. Vine Charcoal

Vine charcoal is made from grape vines or willow branches and is the softest and lightest form of charcoal. It is easily erasable and is perfect for light, airy, and expressive sketches. However, vine charcoal can smudge easily and is better for sharp, detailed drawings.

Vine Charcoal
Compressed Charcoal

2. Compressed Charcoal

Compressed charcoal is made by grinding charcoal and then binding it with gum or wax. It is denser, darker, and available in various hardness levels. This type is excellent for detailed work and deeper tones. It produces less dust than vine charcoal but is more challenging to erase.

3. Charcoal Pencils

Compressed charcoal housed in a wooden pencil provides greater precision and reduces potential mistakes. Charcoal pencils are ideal for detailed work and provide various hardness options. They are suitable for both beginners and advanced artists who appreciate a methodical and meticulous approach to their work.

Charcoal Pencils

Each type of charcoal offers distinct benefits and limitations, making them suitable for different styles and techniques. Understanding these differences can help you make an informed decision about which charcoal best suits your drawing needs.

Consider Your Drawing Style

2. Consider Your Drawing Style

When selecting charcoal, it’s crucial to consider how well it aligns with your drawing style. Different types of charcoal suit different artistic approaches and techniques, so choosing the right one can greatly enhance the quality of your art.

For A Quick Sketching and Capturing Motion

For quick sketches, motion capture, or atmospheric landscapes, vine charcoal is your best bet. Its softer, more erasable nature allows for rapid changes and a wide range of tones, perfect for capturing the ephemeral qualities of light and motion. Its ease of use makes it particularly forgiving for beginners experimenting with their style.

For Detailed Work

For detailed portraits, intricate still lifes, or precise shading, opt for compressed charcoal or charcoal pencils. Compressed charcoal, being denser and darker, offers the ability to create intense, rich blacks and a variety of shades depending on how much pressure you apply. It’s ideal for adding drama and contrast to your drawings.

Charcoal pencils offer precise control and are ideal for fine details like sharp edges and intricate lines in detailed drawings. They’re great for precise work in figurative art as well. These pencils offer a spectrum of hardness options, enabling you to select according to the level of detail and texture you aim to achieve.

For Detailed Work

Choosing charcoal should enhance and not hinder your artistic expression.Experiment with different types to see how each reacts to your touch and technique. Over time, you’ll find the type of charcoal that not only feels right but also complements and elevates your drawing style.

Experiment with Hardness Levels

3. Experiment with Hardness Levels

Charcoal, much like graphite, offers a range of hardness types, each bringing its unique qualities to your artwork. The hardness of the charcoal influences the darkness, texture, and precision of the lines you can achieve, making it essential to choose the right type for your specific artistic needs.

Understanding Hardness Levels

  • Softer Charcoals: These are typically darker and allow for smoother blending. They are excellent for creating rich, deep shadows and bold strokes. However, they can be smudgier, which might be challenging if you’re aiming for a higher level of detail. Vine charcoal usually falls into this category, making it ideal for rapid sketching and atmospheric effects.

Harder Charcoals: These provide lighter, more controlled lines and are less prone to smudging. They are perfect for detailed work where precision is crucial. Compressed charcoal and charcoal pencils can be found in various degrees of hardness, much like their graphite counterparts, allowing for a detailed gradation in your shading and textural effects.

Experimentation is Key

Experimentation is crucial to finding the charcoal that best suits your artistic style. Here are some tips for exploring the different hardness levels:

 

  • Purchase a Variety Pack: Many art suppliers offer charcoal sets with various hardness levels. These sets are a great starting point and typically include a mix of vine, compressed, and pencil forms.
  • Test on Different Papers: The texture and weight of the paper you use can dramatically affect the appearance of your charcoal drawings. Try your chosen charcoal on various papers to see how they interact.
  • Mix and Match: Be bold and use different types of charcoal in the same piece. Softer charcoals can be great for laying down base tones and building atmosphere, while harder charcoals can be used for fine details and crisp edges.

Keep a Sketchbook: Dedicate a sketchbook to experimenting with different charcoals. This helps understand how each type behaves and serves as a reference for future projects.

Experimentation is Key

By taking the time to explore various hardness levels and types, you’ll develop a better understanding of how each can enhance your drawings. This process helps refine your technique and expands your creative possibilities, allowing you to tailor your tools to match your vision perfectly.

Check the Quality

4. Check the Quality

Not all charcoals are created equal. Higher-quality charcoal generally produces richer pigment and smoother texture. When shopping for charcoal, look for brands known for their quality. It might cost more, but the difference in outcome can be worth the investment.

5. Tools and Accessories

To make the most out of your charcoal drawing experience, consider tools and accessories that can accompany your charcoal:

 

  • Fixatives: Charcoal drawings are very prone to smudging. Using a fixative spray can help preserve your work once it’s completed.
  • Blending Tools: Stumps, tortillons, or even tissue paper can be used to blend charcoal for a softer or more unified appearance.
  • Erasers: Investing in a good kneaded eraser will allow you to lighten up dark tones or create highlights, adding depth to your charcoal drawings.
Tools and Accessories

Conclusion

Ultimately, the best way to determine which type of charcoal to draw with is through personal experience. Try different types of charcoal, experiment with various techniques, and see how each reacts on other kinds of paper. Over time, you’ll develop a preference that complements your artistic style.